Ordained Priest | Years | Name | Current Title |
| Most Senior |
| 21 Dec 1935 |
| Bishop Bernard Joseph McLaughlin | Auxiliary Bishop Emeritus of Buffalo, New York |
| 29 Jun 1939 |
| Archbishop Peter Leo Gerety | Archbishop Emeritus of Newark, New Jersey |
| 24 Nov 1940 |
| Bishop Innocent Hilarion Lotocky, O.S.B.M. | Bishop Emeritus of Saint Nicolas of Chicago (Ukrainian), Illinois |
| 24 Feb 1943 |
| Bishop Bernard Ferdinand Popp | Auxiliary Bishop Emeritus of San Antonio, Texas |
| 27 Mar 1943 |
| Bishop Arthur Joseph O’Neill | Bishop Emeritus of Rockford, Illinois |
| 1 May 1943 |
| Bishop Timothy Joseph Lyne | Auxiliary Bishop Emeritus of Chicago, Illinois |
| 19 Jun 1943 |
| Bishop Albert Henry Ottenweller | Bishop Emeritus of Steubenville, Ohio |
| 3 Jun 1944 |
| Bishop Martin Nicholas Lohmuller | Auxiliary Bishop Emeritus of Philadelphia, Pennsylvania |
| 29 Jun 1945 |
| Bishop Joseph Francis Maguire | Bishop Emeritus of Springfield, Massachusetts |
| 6 Apr 1946 |
| Bishop William Anthony Hughes | Bishop Emeritus of Covington, Kentucky |
| 1 Jun 1946 |
| Archbishop Raymond Gerhardt Hunthausen | Archbishop Emeritus of Seattle, Washington |
| 15 Jun 1946 |
| Bishop Francis Anthony Quinn | Bishop Emeritus of Sacramento, California |
| Most Junior |
| 21 Feb 2009 |
| Father Jeffrey Neil Steenson | Ordinary of The Chair of Saint Peter |
| 6 Jun 1998 |
| Bishop James Sean Wall | Bishop of Gallup, New Mexico |
| 23 May 1998 |
| Bishop John Balthasar Brungardt | Bishop of Dodge City, Kansas |
| 24 May 1997 |
| Bishop Alberto Rojas | Auxiliary Bishop of Chicago, Illinois |
| 1 Jun 1996 |
| Bishop José Arturo Cepeda Escobedo | Auxiliary Bishop of Detroit, Michigan |
| 25 May 1996 |
| Bishop Michael Jude Byrnes | Auxiliary Bishop of Detroit, Michigan |
| 25 May 1995 |
| Bishop Neal James Buckon | Auxiliary Bishop of United States of America, Military |
| 7 Jan 1995 |
| Bishop Daniel Fernández Torres | Bishop of Arecibo, Puerto Rico |
| 2 Jul 1994 |
| Bishop Robert Dwayne Gruss | Bishop of Rapid City, South Dakota |
| 25 Jun 1994 |
| Bishop Gintaras Linas Grušas | Bishop of Lithuania, Military |
| 4 Jun 1994 |
| Bishop Joseph Robert Binzer | Auxiliary Bishop of Cincinnati, Ohio |
| 21 May 1994 |
| Bishop Oscar Cantú | Auxiliary Bishop of San Antonio, Texas |